Case T-638/26, Alphabet and Google Ireland v Commission – search data at cost, for rivals and chatbots
The DMA requires Google to share its search data with competitors. The question in this case is how much, with whom, and at what price.
Facts
Article 6(11) DMA requires a gatekeeper to provide any third-party online search engine, at its request, “with access on fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory terms to ranking, query, click and view data in relation to free and paid search”, and requires query, click and view data that constitute personal data to be anonymised. According to the summary of the Commission’s decision of 16 July 2026 in Case DMA.100209, third parties had complained of an anonymisation approach that removed “the large majority of unique queries”, of missing data types, of delays, of pricing that was not FRAND, and of Google’s refusal to treat AI chatbots with search functions as beneficiaries. The decision specifies measures in five areas. Eligibility extends to “AI chatbots that provide OSE functionalities”, subject to criteria including size and the absence of control by a third country posing a serious security or data protection risk. The data scope covers queries, viewed results, ranking and click data, shared daily. Anonymisation combines technical suppression and generalisation with contractual bans on re-identification. Pricing is set at “incremental cost-based pricing”, plus a reasonable return, and there are rules on testing and access. Alphabet and Google Ireland ask the General Court to annul the decision or, in the alternative, to declare Article 6(11) inapplicable under Article 277 TFEU.
Pleas in Law
According to the Official Journal notice, the applicants rely on seven pleas in law:
1. First plea in law, alleging that the decision forces Google to disclose personal data in violation of the DMA, the GDPR and individuals’ fundamental privacy rights.
2. Second plea in law, alleging that the decision imposes modalities for the data disclosures that violate Articles 6(11) and 8 DMA and unlawfully expropriate Google’s innovations.
3. Third plea in law, alleging that the decision requires disclosure of data fields that are outside the scope of the disclosure obligation in violation of Article 6(11) DMA.
4. Fourth plea in law, alleging that the decision imposes a cost-based pricing mechanism that denies Google compensation for the value of its data in violation of Article 6(11) DMA.
5. Fifth plea in law, alleging that the decision specifies an excessively broad eligibility scope in violation of Article 6(11) DMA.
6. Sixth plea in law, alleging that in the alternative, that if Article 6(11) DMA were interpreted as permitting the decision’s measures, Article 6(11) DMA itself would be inapplicable.
7. Seventh plea in law, alleging that the decision is vitiated by procedural defects.
Sources
OJ notice C/2026/5906 (EUR‑Lex) · Case file on CURIA · Summary of the Commission decision in DMA.100209 (OJ C/2026/4443) · Regulation (EU) 2022/1925
Comment
The first plea turns the GDPR against the DMA. Article 6(11) requires personal data to be anonymised, and the Commission’s decision prescribes how. Direct identifiers are suppressed, long and rare queries removed, location and interaction data generalised, sessions limited to three refinements and durations coarsened. Recipients must also accept a ban on re-identification, audits and a 13‑month retention limit. Google’s argument is that data so processed may still be personal data, so that disclosing it requires a GDPR basis the DMA cannot supply. The Commission relied on joint guidelines with the European Data Protection Board on the interplay between the two regimes. The General Court will have to decide whether anonymisation backed in part by contract, rather than by the data alone, is anonymisation at all.
The fourth plea is about price. The DMA requires FRAND terms. The Commission read that, “absent comparable market-based benchmarks”, as incremental cost plus a reasonable return on capital, with an additional margin only in exceptional circumstances. Google says FRAND must reflect the value of the data, not the cost of copying it. The phrase is borrowed from standard-essential patent licensing, where it governs royalties. Whether the same words in a regulation about gatekeepers can mean cost recovery is now a question for the General Court.
The fifth plea concerns the newest point: AI chatbots. Article 6(11) speaks of third-party undertakings “providing online search engines”. By treating chatbots with search functions as search engines for this purpose, the Commission has made Google’s data available to its rivals in generative AI as well as in search. Google says that stretches the provision. It is the same theme as Google’s parallel action on Android, T‑639/26: the Commission is using the DMA to open Google’s systems to AI competitors, and Google is asking the General Court where the Act stops.